Does speed reading work?
Not the way it’s sold. Reading faster than you normally do costs you understanding. Most adults read at 200 to 400 words a minute, and going much faster than that means taking in less of what you read.
By Bug City, the makers of Bounds. Published .
Where this comes from
This page summarises one review: So Much to Read, So Little Time: How Do We Read, and Can Speed Reading Help?, by Rayner, Schotter, Masson, Potter and Treiman, published in Psychological Science in the Public Interest in 2016 (volume 17, issue 1, pages 4–34; DOI 10.1177/1529100615623267). Its five authors went through what is known about how people read and asked whether speed-reading courses and apps can make you read faster without understanding less. It’s free to read in full on the publisher’s site. The studies named below are the ones the review describes.
Speed costs understanding
The review’s main finding is a trade-off: “There is a trade-off between speed and accuracy in reading, as there is in all forms of behavior.” The faster words go by, the less of them you understand and remember.
It finds it unlikely that anyone can double or triple their speed, from around 250 to 500–750 words a minute, and still understand a text as well as at their normal speed. It also puts the normal speed in perspective: 200 to 400 words a minute is faster than we normally take in information by listening, and in the review’s words “pretty good for most purposes”.
What speed-reading courses do
The courses the review looked at mostly teach skimming. In one study (Calef and colleagues, 1999), adults went from about 280 to about 400 words a minute after a speed-reading class, and their comprehension scores fell from 81% to 74%.
The review calls a 1980 study by Just, Masson and Carpenter the most complete. It compared trained speed readers and people told to skim, both at 600–700 words a minute, with normal readers at about 250. The speed readers got the gist better than the skimmers, but not as well as normal readers, and on details they did no better than the skimmers. On technical texts they lost even their edge on the gist. The review concludes that speed-reading students “are essentially being taught to skim”.
The most extreme case: two star graduates of a speed-reading program read a college textbook at 15,000 words a minute or more, and understood little of it. The researcher (Homa, 1983) concluded that what they had learned was “a remarkable dexterity in page-turning”.
Skimming is useful, and it’s not reading
Skimming can be 2 to 4 times faster than ordinary reading, with lower comprehension. That’s often a fair deal: to find a fact, or to get the gist of something you already know about, skimming is the right tool. The review says people who skim well look for headings, paragraph structure and key words, then read those parts carefully. Just don’t expect to understand all of a text you skimmed.
One word at a time (RSVP)
Apps like Spritz flash one word at a time in the same spot, a method called rapid serial visual presentation, or RSVP. The claim is that, with no need to move your eyes, you can read faster. A single sentence shown this way, at about 600 words a minute, is understood well. Whole passages are another matter. In the studies the review describes, readers shown paragraphs at 200, 400 or 600 words a minute understood about as much as normal readers at the slowest speed, but remembered less detail as the speed rose; in one study, scores fell by about 50% at the faster speeds. Without short pauses between sentences, comprehension suffered too.
The one study that measured comprehension with a Spritz-like app let readers pause whenever they liked. They read at about the same speed either way, 209 words a minute with RSVP and 200 reading normally. With RSVP their eyes tired more, and they did worse on questions about what the text literally said, though as well on questions that needed inference. The review’s view is that RSVP apps are unlikely to let people double or triple their speed and still understand moderately complex texts.
Why looking back matters
In one survey of 40 speed-reading books, most advised against looking back. The review finds looking back is how readers fix a misreading. In one experiment (Schotter, Tran and Rayner, 2014), words were hidden once the eyes had passed them. Readers who looked back answered a two-choice question about the sentence correctly 75% of the time when they could reread, and about 50%, no better than guessing, when they couldn’t. RSVP takes that away, and the review notes that many RSVP “go back” buttons simply restart the sentence or the text.
What does help
Practice. The review says reading practice “does help. But it helps slowly and does not cause drastic increases in speed.” What makes the difference is skill with language, not eye control: reading more, and reading varied texts, builds vocabulary and knowledge, and that lets you read faster with the same understanding. Tools that make the next line easier to find, such as colouring lines in a gradient, probably help only a little, because finding the next line isn’t the hard part of reading.
What a steady pace can and can’t do
Bounds scrolls your text at a steady pace you choose. It doesn’t make anyone read faster than they can understand, and nothing in this review suggests a reading app could. Here is what it does and doesn’t do for you.
It can
- Hold the speed you chose, anywhere from 100 to 1,000 words a minute, and let you change it while you read.
- Show whole lines and paragraphs, so you see the sentence around each word instead of one flashed word at a time.
- Let you stop and go back: pause with a tap or the space bar, and Bounds backs up a line when you start again; rewind steps back about ten seconds of reading to the start of a sentence.
- Show your words per minute, in the reading speed test and in your reading stats.
It can’t
- Make you understand faster. Set it faster than you can follow and you get the trade-off the review describes, more words and less understanding.
- Tell you how much you understood. Bounds measures speed, not comprehension, so slow it down when you lose the thread.
- Speed you up much by marking the line. Its focus guides make the next line easy to find, but the review found that finding the next line isn’t the hard part of reading.
- Replace practice. The review says what helps, slowly, is reading more and reading more varied texts.
Find your own speed
The reading speed test times you reading a chapter of a novel and shows your words a minute. The average reading speed page explains what’s typical for adults, from a 2019 review of 190 studies.
- So Much to Read, So Little Time: How Do We Read, and Can Speed Reading Help?. Keith Rayner, Elizabeth R. Schotter, Michael E. J. Masson, Mary C. Potter and Rebecca Treiman. Psychological Science in the Public Interest, volume 17, issue 1, pages 4–34, 2016.